Placeblogging panel - feedback for Lucas Ihlein who couldn’t attend

Penultimo will write up an informal report about this weekend’s Placeblogging Panel discussion (with Meredith Jones, Matt and Polly Levinson, and Linda Carroli) in the next few days, but in the meantime, we wrote this comment about the event on Lucas Ihlein’s Bilateral Blog.

Lucas had some great links to share - ideas about writing about the urban terrain and walking… have a read of his post here. He also asked how the panel went (he couldn’t attend as he was squatspace-ing. Here is our reply. (Now here’s a first - Penultimo speaking in the first person… )

“Hi Lucas

“Bilateral Petersham was indeed mentioned at our little panel discussion on Saturday – though fairly briefly. The way I talked about it was this: I actually think Bilateral Petersham entered into my subconscious at some stage after your show at Artspace (five years ago – crap, that long? wow).

“For me, five years ago, the idea of blogging about a suburb (and as an art project) was something that I was a bit in awe of, because I couldn’t comprehend being able to “speak for” a place. I grew up in Balmain and then moved to Edinburgh, then Darlinghurst – and these are all places that seemed already “spoken for”.

“I remember making the Petersham paper zine and in fact that moment is recorded: I’m in that photo you used of “punters” putting together the book (I’m the blurry one). And now your lovely girlfriend keeps me busy working on multiple projects. But that’s another story.

“As for how the panel went on Saturday – I’m still digesting the content, so I’ll only say a little here. Our panel was very diverse; the topics went many different directions. I’ll write up an informal report about it in a few days time and post it on Penultimo.

“What really seemed to get the audience going was this question of: who were we writing for? Also, the class and demographic resonances of place blogging were a key point. We talked about our concerns about being participants in gentrification – and one audience member joked: Has a suburb “gentrified” by the time you have someone blogging about it? In this sort of sense – blogging about your suburb seems to be an activity that is confined to privileged inner city types with multiple degrees. Ok, not always, but there is a fairly clear pattern. Whether or not this is OK was one issue. People asked – does no one blog about the western suburbs of Sydney because they’re not WALKING out there, they’re driving?

“We also talked about “urban planning literacy” and whether placeblogs have a role distilling complex planning information into digestible content (because, let’s face it, planning is a mystery to everyone except those who work in the field, and those who have wrestled with Councils over DAs and DA objections). I suppose they can work that way, but only if authors want to take on that responsibility. Each panellist had a different level of political engagement and a different way of speaking about place: from what Matt and Polly described as a “prosaic” presentation of things that they see in their local area, to Linda Carroli’s background in community action / activist worlds, and her despair at the state of Brisbane’s outer suburbs.

“Just as the discussion was getting interesting I looked at my watch and realised we had run overtime. There was so much more to discuss.”